Aaron (webmaster) I thought the 5th book wasn't as good as the others. I didn't like how Harry got mad at everything. Yes, he has a lot of stress but don't you think he could have been a little nicer to other people instead of being a whinny baby. I didn't like how he blamed Snape for everthing. Snape did everything he could about Sirius. Don't get me wrong, I LOVED the book but it wasn't my favorite.
April (webmistriss) I think that the fifth Harry potter book was awesome despite all of the sad things that happen. When you are reading it you actually feel sad for Harry or angry for Harry or happy for him. Even though Harry is not real, you get into the book that was the best book i have ever read! JK Rowling strikes again! She has not yet lost her touch!!!
Andrea: "i love the hp series but this was definitaly not my favorite book of them all! it was was totaly different than the others. too different! don't get me wrong, i love the books.the worst part was that everyone was a butt! harry yelled to much. the chances are that if u were to just open the book to any page, he or someone else would be yelling their head off. it's kinda violent ( but intresting)! dumbldore got on my last nerve. after all harry has been through he should have told harry in year 3! then sirius( my absolute favorite character) wouldn't have died!-- I CRIED ALL NIGHT-- and u can ask hannah b. she was there! and it is hard to get me mad - i'm always happy-ask hannah,miranda(guest book),aaron, or april. they know!! ron and hermione acted like sidekicks or lackies, they r supposed to be friends! kreacher, i want to chop off his head and put it on a dinner plate b/c he was a BEEP.i'll make his dream come true. cho is very lost. she needs to pick a guy and stay with him. i understand she's sad but she can't do this to harry. no guy deerves it. other than these few minor mishaps it was a really good book. lupin was awesome! sirius was cool (up until he died). and it had a great story line. whoever reads this is gonna think i'm a nut but i love harry potter. and last but definitely not least sean biggerstaff (oliver wood) is the hottie with an accent."
Kelsi
I THINK THE BOOK WAS FRIGGIN' AWESOME!!! And the people who disagree have problems. I like the way Harry got mad at everything. It shows everyone that Harry has his faults, like all human beings. (Plus, if Harry were real, he'd look cute when he's mad...dare to dream...) I also think that Cho has problems. SHE NEEDS TO STOP CRYING!!! And she needs to make up her stinkin' mind! It aggrevates me to no end the way she latches on to Harry and leads him on, just so she can make him relive the worst night of his life! I can think of a word that rhymes with Cho... I'll give you a hint, it starts with H...hmmmmmmm, mysterious... Well, anyway, I SO cried when Sirius died. Not because he died, but of the way Harry went into complete denial afterwards. *Sniff* So sad. That being said, I am so ready for the next book. Maybe ol' J.K. will get off her butt and..oh, maybe HURRY UP!
Erin: I think that it was a very good book. And I think it is my favorite of all of them. I think I connected better with Harry since in this book him and I are the same age and that we are both going through stressful times and are sick of being underestimated. Yes ther was alot of anger and rage, but can you blame Harry for blowing up when people won't tell him things he needs to know. He's held in the anger for too long and needs to start expressing him self more. Then maybe he won't blow up quiet as badly. This is just my opion.
Kaley:
|
I thought book 5 was the best one yet. I loved the action, and all the emotions. You feel anger, sadness, humor sometimes, and even romance! I felt sorry for Harry when he was yelling sometimes because it seemed to me that Ron and Hermione didn't understand why he was mad, and I know how that feels! It was sooooo sad when Sirius died tho! I was worried the seeing the dead Ron boggart was some kind of foreshadowing tho!! That scared me. Then the brain thingy I thought for sure it was gonna be him! It was still an awesome book tho!
|
Alyssa: My first impression was that it was VERY different from the other ones. It was a lot more, angry, angsty, depressing. This was kind of interesting, but I got a little tired of poor martyred Harry's temper tantrums. And I REALLY wish Sirius hadn't died, he had the whole bad-boy-dark-mysterious-been-in-azkaban-reckless-hero thing going on. HE should have died a more noble death (if at ALL) if you ask me.
